Site Navigation
HomeAbout
Services
Testimonials
Contact
Info
The Surprise Shop
"Come On In And Be Surprised! You’ll Never Know What You Will Find!"
About Us
The Surprise Shop is a beloved local destination in Sullivan, MO, that has been proudly serving the surrounding areas since 1992. We offer a delightful array of collectibles, trading card games, toys, comics, books, and many more surprises to treasure. Our carefully curated selections cater to all age groups and interests, making us a one-stop shop for entertainment enthusiasts. Whether you're hunting for rare finds or seeking unique gifts, our diverse selection has something for everyone. Come explore our store where the joy of discovery awaits!
Areas Served
Franklin County, MO | Crawford County, MO | Phelps County, MO | Washington County, MO | Sullivan, MO | Rolla, MO | Cuba, MO | St. Louis, MO
What We Offer
Our Specialties include:
- Helping Local Artists Rise in the Community
Our Services include:
- Buying
- Selling
- Trading
- Disc Repair
- Players Room
- Activity Area
Our Brands include:
- TCGplayer
- Funko
- Wizards Play Network
- Magic: The Gathering
- Hot Wheels
- Pokemon
- The ARmy Paiters
- Wiz Kids
- Bandi
- Namco
- Hazburro Toys
- Dungeons & Dragons
- Yuh-Gi Yoh
- Rivel
- Dragon Shield
Our Products include:
- Collectibles
- Novelties
- Knick Knacks
- Gifts
- Sports Memorabilia
- New Toys
- Old Toys
- Cards
- Sports Cards
- Anime Collectibles
- Vintage Toys
- Card Games
- Video Games
- Board Games
- Movies
- DVDs
- Antiques
- Resale Items
- Action Figures
- Model Cars
- Model Airplanes
- Apparel
- Books
- Comic Books
- Vinyl Records
- Local Art
Testimonials
On 9/2/2025
SHERRY BROWN
had this to say:
Took my grandkids in about a month ago,ages 3,an4 they had a blast! The owner is very nice! We made our purchases, and had a great day! So glad to have made memories with them in a toy store, since there are so few left. We will be back for sure! Thank-you for what felt like 2 hours of playtime and exploration!
On 8/17/2025
Lucas Greiner
had this to say:
Coolest collection I have seen in a while! I found some older pokemon stuff and cool hot wheels stuff. I will be going back
On 8/14/2025
Amy W
had this to say:
This store is so cool, there's so much cool stuff and the new location is great!
On 7/31/2025
sally “Sassy”
had this to say:
I have been going to this store for many years . Even tbough i live in Pennsylvania i became very good with the previous owner on a first name basis. We go into this store every year and have brought family members in to introduce them to this very interesting store. The store has changed owner and new location but still love to visit. John who was behind the counter recognized me rite away and it was nice to feel familiar. Will continue to visit and always buy if I find a treasure. Thank you
On 7/26/2025
Dan Woods
had this to say:
Pretty cool. A little pricey though
Contact Us
The Surprise Shop
134 W Main St Sullivan, MO 63080
Phone: (573) 468-6932
Email: thesurpriseshopllc
Where To Find Us
Follow us on FacebookPayment Types Accepted
American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, PayPal, Visa, Venmo, Zelle, Cash App
Our Hours
Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.
Monday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sunday: By Appointment Only
Info
Ebay Shop!Legal
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy